Yesterday I took part in a panel discussion at Lewis and Clark College's current conference on "Reimagining the Good Life." Our panel's subject was the relationship between economics and religion, in attaining "the good life." I opened with the following three-minute statement, which I'm sharing with readers as my "Reflection" for this week:
I remember the first time I began to understand that our economic system could be questioned, that it was not just a given, but actually the product of human choice. I was a social work student, back in the '70's, and I heard a speech by David Gil, a professor from Brandeis. "Who owns the air?" he said. "Who owns the water?"
A word about the ancient god of the free market system, Adam Smith. When Smith is quoted regarding the "invisible hand" of the market, what is conveniently forgotten is his assumptions about the conditions necessary to make free markets work. Smith assumed that we would operate on a small scale and so would know the character of the people we trade with. He assumed that our financial dealings would exist in the context of our values. Instead, Smith's writing is used to justify the mad pursuit of shareholder profit, which is held to be holy and untouchable.
If we consider ourselves religious or spiritual, we know that we must see and enter the suffering of the world, else our own spiritual wounds will never heal. The question comes, though, how do we enter the suffering of the world? Churches are most comfortable with deeds of charity alone. I recall the words of Archbishop Camara of Brazil: "When I give food to the poor, they call me a saint; when I ask why the poor have no food, they call me a Communist." There's nothing wrong with giving soup to hungry people--but the more difficult and dangerous way is systemic change, to get at the system that causes the suffering.
Wendell Berry looked at the derivation of "economics" in his book Home Economics. Originally the word meant "activity involved in caring for the home." Now it is a sophisticated discipline, supposedly a science, grounded in mathematical equations instead of human values.
Do I, a minister, know enough to speak about economics? Am I a citizen? We cannot leave this crucial area to the "experts," who have overlooked the poor among us, saying "that's just the price we have to pay for prosperity"; who have called the bleeding of the earth an "externality"; who have been enamored of formulas in books and have not been concerned that children are hungry. No, we can't leave economics to the experts, because economics is all about how we divvy up resources and therefore it is fundamentally a moral issue.
We wonder that we can do in the face of forces which seem immovable. Well, these forces are in fact subject to change. Human beings have made choices, and different choices can be made. We can say no, and no, and no. We can say no, until they hear us. And we can say yes, here is a new way. It's time now. Let's move there together.
Share this
I certainly agree with you that economics involves moral issues, and that economic debates should not be the sole province of economists. I welcome the involvement of ministers, philosphers, and a wide variety of citizens in economic debates.
But do you really believe that most economists think that the poor are "just the price we have to pay for prosperity"? I am an economist, and I know many economists, and I do not think this is even close to a widely held view in economics. I think you're attacking a straw man.
I could list many prominent economists who believe that there is an important moral dimension to economic debates: Amartya Sen, Rebecca Blank, and Benjamin Friedman, for example. Sen is a Nobel prize winner who has widely written on theories of justice. Blank is a former member of the Council of Economic Advisors, currently serving as Under Secretary of Commerce, who wrote a book on economic justice that was used as a teaching tool by the United Church of Christ. Benjamin Friedman is a Harvard economist who wrote a book in 2005 entitled "The Moral Consequences of Economic Growth".
Interesting response--I know there are many caring folks out there in all fields, including economics--thanks for writing with specifics--
It is true that economics cannot be left with experts. We use economics in our day to day life too. The demand and supply cycle of economics has a great impact on our life. How can we ignore all these facts? With all these debates going in different website I am also on the same side who thinks economics should always go with moral values. It is good to help poor but it is better to eradicate poverty from its root. Such eradication can be done only with the help of politicians who have major part to play in decision making policies for the country as a whole.
This volume presents mill valley lash tintlearn exotic dance online
This is a great post it was very informative. I look forward in reading more of your work. Also, I made sure to bookmark your website so I can come back later. I enjoyed every moment of reading it.
-commercial van insurance
My brain being satisfying to sensible writing at this site similar my muscles to whey protein powders, however the first is much pleasant and useful
As the saying goes - mixing politics with religion is like mixing oil and water. It just doesn't mix at all. Gerry of copper kitchen sinks site.
There are plenty of information about this topic in the net & some are definitely better than others.
Attic Conversion
This is a great inspiring article. I am pretty much pleased with your good work. You put really very helpful information. Keep it up. Keep blogging. Looking to reading your next post.
Ronald @ traders insurance
Today, hydrogen retin-a gas is usually generated using a platinum catalyst about 70 times more expensive than Karunadasa’s new catalyst or by reacting water and natural gas at high temperatures, a process that still relies on fossil fuels. In addition to being very expensive, the surface imitrex about of the platinum catalyst gets coated by impurities in water becoming ineffective over time.
With weight loss, people get a significant improvement to health slimex 10mg.
Set realistic goals for weight loss and you will feel the difference, since only the loss of 5-10% slimex
of its original weight, it reduces the risk of diseases such as heart disease and diabetes.buy slimex 15 mg
You must be aware that you really have an awesome site. Does exactly what it sets out to do. Stimulating me to read much more of your post. OC small business consulting
Hope to see a lot more excellent posts from you shortly.
There are a lot of motivating views and opinions. I think that you certainly discovered an significant fact. kenny chesney tickets || billy currington tickets ||bob dylan tickets
Well. This is really very certify that this is being very wrong this time. San Diego Business Coaching
Thanks for taking time to discuss this subject. Fortunately this topic is presented in your blog, assuring a decent coverage. Keep it up good work !
p90x
does p90x work
Thank you for providing the perspective. I just read a part of the article,so I don't know much what to say. Good luck for the new member!
Lynx @ steel suppliers
This post shows the information which is close to standard. Hope next You will again post a nice Article/Information.
marin day spa
There are plenty of information about this topic in the net & some are definitely better than others.
Plasterboard Fixings
I remember the first time I began to understand that our economic system could be compromised, that it was not just one, but in fact the product of human choice. I was a student of social work at Century 70, and I heard a speech by David Gil, a professor at Brandeis. "Who owns the air?" he said. "Who owns the water?"
cheap auto insurance
Author who is a very literary talent, writing experience, a person's writing skills and experience is very relevant,Costa Rica Long Term Rentals the experience can make the article with reality, a good article can not be divorced from reality, and only with the realities of the article is the best article, the role of large, practical, only relatively strong.Costa Rica Real Estate
I mean I just read through the entire article of yours and it was quite good but since I'm more of a visual learner. Have you ever considered adding more videos to your blog posts to keep the readers more entertained?,I found that to be more helpful well let me know how it turns out! I love what you guys are always up too. Such clever work and reporting! ford trucks ged math practice test ged training
i think this is good,strange & appreciating.....there is no doubt in this that we are now in that kind of world where wer come across different and strange things happening in this world. Innovation is everywhere, personally I am also a fan of innovation, no matter in studies, technologies, science, beauty, fashion (but it should be good for human kind an world). In recent past it was just ok to get a master degree in any of the running field and set your career we are much more into virtual studies 1z0-053 dumps | 000-152 dumps | 650-295 dumps | E20-322 dumps and doing all those stuffs where we can explore and learn more.. a lot certifications introduced by Microsoft, Cisco and other international certifications in which you can study and get a good career too. I am so happy to be part of this revolutionary field and do suggest you too. because at the end "it always up to you to decide"...thanks!!
there is no doubt that we are now in a world where we come across different and strange things happening in this world. Innovation is everywhere, personally I am also a fan of innovation, no matter in studies, technologies, science, beauty. In recent past it was just ok to get a master degree in any of the running field and set your career we are much more into virtual studies like 642-661 dumps | 350-050 dumps |642-627 dumps | JN0-632 dumps and doing all those stuffs where we can explore and learn more.. a lot certifications introduced by Microsoft, isco and other international certifications in which you can study and get a good career too. I am so happy to be part of this revolutionary field and do suggest you too. because at the end "it always up to you to decide"...thanks!!
This is a great post it was very informative. I look forward in reading more of your work. Also, I made sure to bookmark your website so I can come back later. I enjoyed every moment of reading it.
online book stores dg electrolux appliances reviews
Congratulations!! What a fabulous event it must have been. I am teary-eyed just hearing about the opening! I can hardly wait to see the film in Portlandsunflower seeds kernels
Congratulations!! What a fabulous event it must have been. I am teary-eyed just hearing about the opening! I can hardly wait to see the film in Portlandsunflower seeds kernels
I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I don’t know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog. I will keep visiting this blog very often.It is a appreciable that you are too good to manage your blog because actual meaning of blog dies if irrelevant comments remain for long time.For good post knowledge based comments should be written so that people can learn from this blog.testking | pass4sure mcitp | pass4sure mcts | pass4sure mcdba | pass4sure mcdst | pass4sure microsoft certification |pass4sure windows 7 | pass4sure mcp
Politics and Religion are best kept way apart from each other. Mixing them isnt a very good idea in my honest opinion.
cheap flight
I have never thought that surfing online can be so much beneficial and having found your blog. I feel happy. I write my short comment on this article. It is awesome.
hopkins vs dawson | dawson vs hopkins | hopkins vs dawson fight | hopkins vs dawson live streaming
You address Testking 000-107 truth issue on that topic Testking 642-384. I think you handled it in a professional manner. Hope you will continue this way, with your Testking 640-461 brilliant ability of writing.
I don’t know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog. I will keep visiting this blog very often. press release pendidikan karakter
pendidikan karakter artikel direktori
indonesia press release berita press media
artikel press release indonesia press
artikel direktori submit artikel
cerdas Web Id bisnis online belajar
SEO Artikel Direktori Blog cerdas
seo article directory Yudinet
id blog Edublogs.org
Blog.com mbah yudinet Blank Book
Cupu Book Wah YudiNet Twitt Feed Yudinet
Feed Personalisblog press feed press
rss press yudinet Com yudinet
press id
I do, consequently do very lots of you Louboutin red-colored Louboutin Dillian Pumps shoes is ordinarily a renowned name one of numerous style circle, as it's the particular sexiest shoes on this Louboutin Declic Pumps planet.
There's a great documentary called "who's got god's millions". Like it or not, the catholic church is mega rich. That's why it's important to separate what's from humans and what's the true message of the infinite creator.
Hello, I'm sure it's really fascinating content, along with tour to cheap new york hotels
This is a nice post in an interesting line of content.Thanks for sharing this article, great way of bring this topic to discussion.Plagiarism checker
The relationship between these two (Economics and Religion) totally makes sense.